Fact checking...
Apr 11, 2013 | 830 views | 0 0 comments | 7 7 recommendations | email to a friend | print
In last week’s Times-Independent there was a story about the two rallies opposing and supporting the creation of a Greater Canyonlands National Monument. One quote in the story intrigued me.

James W. Tibbetts, chairman of the Sagebrush Coalition’s board of directors, which oppose the proposed monument, was quoted as saying, “2 trillion tons of low sulfur coal was taken off the market when President Bill Clinton declared the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument.” Two trillion tons is a big number and I became curious about its accuracy.

A few seconds, literally a few seconds, with my search engine of choice pointed me to a report by the Utah Geologic Survey on the energy resources of the Grand Staircase area. That report put the total coal resources on federal, state, and private land in the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument at 62.3 billion tons, of which 11.4 billon tons was recoverable. Mr. Tibbetts’s number of 2 trillion tons was off by a factor of about 200 (11.4 billion instead of 2 trillion). Perhaps the giddy excitement and fumes of Jeep Safari had addled him.

There are two conclusions a fact-friendly reader can draw. One, Mr. Tibbetts apparently pulled a number out of the air, or somewhere, and wouldn’t recognize a fact if it bit him on the ankle, or somewhere. Second, The Times-Independent presented Mr. Tibbetts nonsense as fact without doing any basic checking of its own.

A newspaper should do more than report “what he said.” A newspaper should report “what he said” and then do some checking and, if warranted, add “and he was wrong.” If all the T-I does is serve as stenographers, what value do you add?

There are smart, committed, and concerned folks working at the T-I. Let them be journalists rather than stenographers.

—Richard Schwartz

Castleton

Copyright 2013 The Times-Independent. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

report abuse...

Express yourself:

We're glad to give readers a forum to express their points of view on issues important to this community. That forum is the “Letters to the Editor.” Letters to the editor may be submitted directly to The Times-Independent through this link and will be published in the print edition of the newspaper. All letters must be the original work of the letter writer – form letters will not be accepted. All letters must include the actual first and last name of the letter writer, the writer’s address, city and state and telephone number. Anonymous letters will not be accepted.

Letters may not exceed 400 words in length, must be regarding issues of general interest to the community, and may not include personal attacks, offensive language, ethnic or racial slurs, or attacks on personal or religious beliefs. Letters should focus on a single issue. Letters that proselytize or focus on theological debates will not be published. During political campaigns, The Times-Independent will not publish letters supporting or opposing any local candidate. Thank you letters are generally not accepted for publication unless the letter has a public purpose. Thank you letters dealing with private matters that compliment or complain about a business or individual will not be published. Nor will letters listing the names of individuals and/or businesses that supported a cause or event. Thank you letters about good Samaritan acts will be considered at the discretion of the newspaper.